APPRAISER'S QUALIFICATIONS
MAI - Appraisal Institute, Certificate #6469
SRPA Member, Society of Real Estate Appraisers, Certificate #902304
SRA Member, Appraisal Institute, Certificate #1088
State-Certified General Real Estate Appraiser No. RZ 0000864
CEO - Broom, Moody, Johnson and Grainger, Inc.
Thirty-six (36) years appraising experience
Graduate - University of North Florida, 1974, BBA Degree, Major - Land Economics
President of Society of Real Estate Appraisers, Jacksonville Chapter 72, 1983
President of the East Florida Chapter of the Appraisal Institute, 1997
Registered Real Estate Broker, State of Florida
Member of Jacksonville Board of Realtors
Member of Association of Eminent Domain Professionals (AEDP)
Instructor - Residential Valuation - American Institute of Real Estate Appraisers, 1981
Served as Special Master - Tax Adjustment Board, 1983
Qualified as expert witness in Circuit and State Courts in the State of Florida
FNMA Approved Appraiser #1046710
APPRAISAL EXPERIENCE:
36 years experience appraising many types of Real Estate, including:
Office Buildings
Shopping Centers
Apartment and Condominium Projects
Manufacturing Distribution Facilities
Service Stations
Mobile Home Parks
Warehouses and Industrial Projects
Residential Subdivisions
Extensive Eminent Domain/Condemnation Appraisals
Residential, Commercial and Industrial Land
Single-Family and Multi-Family Homes
Hospitals and Nursing Homes
Country Club Communities
Market and Feasibility Studies
Hotels/Motels
Emergency Care Centers
Mini-Warehouses
Churches
The following Real Estate Courses and Seminars have been successfully completed:
Subdivision Analysis - AIREA, (1986)
Electronic Spreadsheet - AIREA, (1986)
Update to Standards of Professional Practice - AIREA, (1986)
Cash Equivalency Seminar - AIREA, (1986)
Federal Home Loan Bank Board Regulation Book R-41C - AIREA, (1987)
Litigation Valuation Course - AIREA, (1987)
Faculty Training Seminar/Faculty Workshop - AIREA, (1988)
Demonstration Appraisal Report Graders Training Session -AIREA, (1988)
Highest and Best Use Seminar - AIREA, (1988)
Demonstration Report Writing Seminar - Grader's Training - AIREA, (1988)
Regional Ethics and Counseling Panel Members Training Program - AIREA, (1989)
Standards of Professional Practice Update - AIREA, (1989)
Valuation Litigation Mock Trial - AIREA, (1989)
Persuasive Style in Appraisal Report Writing - AIREA, (1990)
Appraisal Theory Review - Appraisal Institute, (1991)
Discounted Cash Flow Analysis - Appraisal Institute, (1991)
Condemnation: Legal rules & Appraisal Practice - Appraisal Institute, (1992)
Review and Update of USPAP/Law - Appraisal Institute, (1992)
Litigation Valuation, SFCCAI (1993)
Mock Trial, SFCCAI (1993)
Florida Core Law Seminar (1994)
Understanding Limited Appraisals and Reporting Options - General (1994)
Appraisal Practices for Litigation (1995)
Electro-Magnetic Fields (1995)
Case Law and How it Affects the Experts Valuation (1996)
Data Confirmation and Verification Methods (1996)
Rates, Ratios and Reasonableness (1996)
Review and Update of USPAP/Law - Appraisal Institute, (1996)
The Internet and Appraising (1997)
Florida Condemnation Valuation & Appraiser Liability Seminar (1997)
Standards of Professional Practice (Part C) (1997)
New Industrial Valuation (1997)
The Appraisal of Real Estate, 10th v. 11th edition (1998)
Appraisal Office Management (1998)
Rates & Ratios Used in the Income Capitalization Approach (1998)
Florida Real Estate Appraisers License law Update (1998)
Valuation of Local Retail Properties (1999)
Association of Eminent Domain Professionals Quarterly Meeting (2000)
Intro. to Appraising & Analysis of Proposed Subdivisions & Condominiums A.I. (2002)
Houses to Hotels The Income Approach The Appraisal Institute (2002)
Succeeding as an Expert Witness Assoc. of Eminent Domain Professionals (2003)
The Evolution of Eminent Domain in the State of Florida Assoc. of Eminent Domain Professionals (2003)
Course 400 USPAP Update ((2004)
Florida State Law, the Appraisal Institute (2004)
Florida Broker Update (2004)
AEDP Quarterly Meeting (2004)
Florida Real Estate Institute Continuing Education Course by Correspondence (2004-2005)
AEDP Fall Conference Eminent Domain (2005)
Subdivision Analysis (2006)
Valuation & Litigation Services SIG (2006)
USPAP Standards Course & Core Law (2006)
AEDP Fall Conference (2006)
Appraisal Institute Business Practices & Ethics (2007)
Appraisal Institute USPAP Update, Florida Law & Supervisory Appraiser (2008)
Appraisal Institute The Valuation of Wetlands (2008)
AEDP Eminent Domain Forum Conference (2008)
PARTIAL LIST OF CLIENTS
Ameris Bank (f/k/a First National Bank of Orange Park)
Bank of America
Jax Navy Federal Credit Union
Bell South
Brigham Moore, LLP
Veterans Administration
U.S. Department of Justice
Federal Reserve Bank of Atlanta
Rogers, Towers, Bailey, Jones & Gay, P.A.
Federal Housing Administration
Pappas, Metcalf, Jenks, Miller & Reinsch
William Coalson, Esquire
Foley & Lardner, P.A.
CTX Mortgage Company
Smith, Hulsey & Busey, P.A.
Compass Bank
First South Bank
First Coast Community Bank
Duval County School Board
Foerster, Isaac & Yerkes, P.A.
Mercantile Bank
First Citizens Bank
BB&T
Davidson Development (World Golf Village)
Colonial Bank Group
Birchfield & Humphrey
Paul Harden, Attorney at Law
Florida Communities Trust
Bank Atlantic
SunTrust Mortgage, Inc.
SouthTrust Bank
Jacksonville Economic Development Co.
Synovus Bank
State of Florida (Dept. of Environmental Protection)
Federal Deposit Insurance Corporation (F.D.I.C.)
Atlantic States Bank
Regency Group, Inc.
State Farm Insurance Company
The Jacksonville Bank
Internal Revenue Service (I.R.S.)
City of Jacksonville, Real Estate Department
Department of Environmental Protection (DEP)
Jacksonville Port Authority (JPA)
Jacksonville Electric Authority (JEA)
Jacksonville Transportation Authority (JTA)
St. Johns County Real Estate Division
City of Jacksonville, Real Estate Dept.
SAMPLE PROJECTS COMPLETED
Jacksonville Shipyard Properties (tax litigation)
Barnett Office Park
LaVilla/Jacksonville Renaissance Project
Koger Properties Office Buildings and Shopping Centers (Florida, Georgia, Alabama and Texas)
World Golf Village Project- Various site developments
Ryans Family Steakhouse Restaurants (State-wide)
Jacksonville Metro area Burger King Restaurants
City of Jacksonville - Various Right-of-Way Assignments and Special Projects (Sports Complex, etc.)
JPA - Dames Point Blount Island Project
Various JTA Projects
Beaches Developments (South Beach Regional Shopping Center, Sawgrass Country Club, Marsh Landing Country Club, The Lodge at Ponte Vedra, Ponte Vedra Country Club, The Plantation Country Club)
Ritz-Carlton, Amelia Island
Omni Hotel, Jacksonville
Independent Life Office Building
The Jacksonville Landing Festival Center
Jacksonville Beach Redevelopment Project
Marriott @ Sawgrass, Ponte Vedra
City of Jacksonville Beach - Various City owned parcels
Golf & Country Club Developments (Champions, Timuquana, Orange Park Country Clubs)
A-B Distributors Warehouses
Sawmill Lakes Proposed PUD Subdivision - Fernandina Beach
Gateway Commons Office Condos (Proposed), Fernandina Beach
Medical Buildings in Duval and Clay Counties
Varous Restaurant sites throughout Duval, Clay & St Johns Counties
New Life Christian Fellowship (Church and Vacant Land)
Deermeadows Baptist Church
American Bank of the South - Merritt Island/Cocoa Beach area locations (acquisition)
Harbour Island Development, Phases I and II - Ponte Vedra Beach
Cumberland Island National Seashore
Fort George Island - Timucuan Preserve areas
Duval County Fairgrounds
Clay County Port and Reynolds Industrial Park
Oyster Bay Residential Development - Fernandina Beach
Imeson Industrial Center
Various Office Buildings throughout Duval and Clay Counties
Huntley-Jiffy Gas Station & Lube Facilities/Convenience Store Properties - North and South Florida
Apartment Projects (The Dunes, The Registry, Boardwalk, Spinnaker Reach, The Paddock Club)
Proposed Auto Dealerships
Various sites for Duval/Clay & St. Johns County School District
Various Walmart Stores
Several Watson Realty Offices and properties
Prudential Plaza One Office Building, Jacksonville
Hampton Professional Office Park
Out parcels in St Johns Town Center
Market Studies Various DRI land in Duval and Clay County
Stellar Office Building Project
Various Sites for St. Johns County Real Estate Division
Various Bank sites
Florida Dept. of Transportation Projects
Bartram Executive Park
Florida Dept. of Environmental Protection Projects
SAMPLE LITIGATION CASES OR EXPERT WITNESS PROJECTS
FOR RONALD K. MOODY OR FARLEY J. GRAINGER
Clay County Port & Reynolds Ind. Park
Independent Life Building
JEA v AFI Assoc.
Jacksonville Landing
ABC Liquors v DOT
City of Jacksonville v Lake Shore Radiator
4570 Mayport Road
Cheney v Sentinel Corp.
Pace, Inc. v Uniman Paving
DOT v Pepe
US v Windsor Corp.
JTA v Golfair Industrial, Inc.
DOT v Hunt
Harris Specialty v U.S. Fire Ins.
DOT v Bent Creek Joint Venture
Beal Bank v Bryan Simpson
DOT v King
DOT v Waring
Hidden Village Apartments
DOT v Mulcahey
DOT v Alford
Timuquana Country Club
10880 103rd St.
DOT v. F. Griffin
City of Jacksonville v Refuse Services
DOT v Tanner
City of Jacksonville Beach v Johnson
City of Jacksonville v Lyon
DOT v Johnson
City of Jax v Gran Central Corporation
DOT v Giddings
City of Jax v Faour, et al
U.S. 301 Project
WRH Mortgage v Izell Blunt
DOT v Florida Septic, Inc.
DOT v Dawkins
City of Jacksonville v Price-Turner
City of Jacksonville v Saunders
DOT v Condaxis
DOT v Fraze
DOT v Ethridge
DOT v Ford
City of Jacksonville Beach v Talpalar
DOT v Ennis (Virginia Gells)
DOT v Ennis (Lillian)
DOT v Slaughter
DOT v Warwick
DOT v Nixon
DOT v Gilbert
DOT v Revels
DOT v Duval Fair Assn
St. Johns Co. School Board v Woody
DOT v Hunter
City of Jacksonville v McClean, et al
City of Jacksonville v Waller, et al
DOT v Beauchamp
DOT v Patrick Burton
Raymond H. Norton
DOT v Moss
Jacksonville Shipyards, Inc.
CSX Transportation
DOT v Morocco Temple
City of Jacksonville v Zep Properties
City of Jacksonville v Peter Denunzio, et al
DOT v Watson Realty
Fannie Mae v Tyrone Smith
City of Jacksonville v Custom Marine
JTA v H. Ray McPhail, et al
DOT v Edwards
Clay Co. School Board v Koehler
JTA v Ms. Era B. Hubbard
DOT v Surface Technologies
4951 Richard Street (BellSouth Facility)
City of Jacksonville Sports Complex Project
JTA Wonderwood Connector Project
JTA vs. Bull (Spoil Island)
JTA vs. The Dunes Apartments
Watson vs City of Gainesville
JTA Arlington Expressway Project
JEA vs A-B Distributors
Arlington Executive Park Litigation
Browns Dump Litigation (Landowners vs City)
